The debate over James Talarico calling God "nonbinary" is silly because it shouldn't be a debate. It is scripturally true.
God is everything. God is everyone. God is every gender. Case closed.
But we get into this ridiculous convo because conservatives find it Very Important to describe God as masculine. More importantly, they demand God be described as a man.
Several years ago, I did a segment on MSNBC and referred to God with "she/her" pronouns. I wasn't being political with that. I really wasn't. That's just how I refer to God, and it is scripturally sound even if conservatives swear it isn't.
So, this rightwing reporter reaches out to me on LinkedIn because he watched the segment, and he was quite upset with me for using she/her pronouns in reference to God.
I asked him: "What is your scientific argument that God is male? Do we know anything about his anatomy?"
He responds: "No, of course not. It's because God is referred to as 'he' and 'him' all throughout Scripture."
And I said: "So, let me get this straight: you have no scientific evidence that God is male, no descriptions of God's anatomy that would support that claim, but because God identifies as male and uses he/him pronouns, you respect and honor that. What does that sound like to you?"
And he started typing and then he stopped typing and then he blocked me.
These folks are loons and we should call them loons and we should challenge them on Scripture and we shouldn't back down from that conversation.
So, yeah, I think James Talarico is spot-on and I give thanks to God, in all Her wisdom, that She inspires him to speak the truth.